|
EU Banking Sector Integration Falls Short of Expectations
Authors: Erik Berglöf (SITE, Stockholm School of Economics and CEPR), Paolo Fulghieri (University of North Carolina and CEPR), Jordi Gual (IESE Business School and CEPR), Colin Mayer (Saïd Business School and CEPR), Pedro Luis Pita Barros (Universidade Nova de Lisboa and CEPR) and Xavier Vives (INSEAD, ICREA-UPF, and CEPR).
A new Report published by the Centre for Economic Policy Research (CEPR) examines the changes
that have taken place in banking in the European Union over the last few years.
The authors of the
third title in CEPR's Monitoring European Deregulation (MED) series 'Integration of European
Banking - The Way Forward' note that perhaps the most significant development that has taken
place in this sector has been the launch of the Financial Services Action Plan (FSAP). The goal
of the FSAP is to create a single integrated market in Financial Services in Europe.
This Report reviews progress that has been made in eliminating regulatory and non-regulatory
barriers to trade in banking services and the degree to which European banking markets have become
integrated.
The authors document a variable level of integration in banking. It is high in wholesale
banking and in certain areas of corporate finance, modest in relationship aspects of banking, low in
retail banking, and patchy and heavily dependent on foreign financial institutions in the accession
countries.
The authors argue that the increase in competition brought about by the introduction of
the euro and more recent deregulation measures has been relatively small.
To them the surprising feature of Europe's liberalization and deregulation in banking is not
that the integration is incomplete. The surprise is that market integration in some areas falls
so short of expectations.
The Report argues that care needs to be taken not to attempt to correct
perceived low levels of integration through excessive harmonization of regulation in areas in which
only modest amounts of integration can be expected. However, the authors reject the use of arguments
about ownership and relationship banking to justify the retention of artificial
barriers to integration.
The Report recommends that further efforts are required to eliminate these barriers through:
-
The establishment of institutions to ensure the effective implementation and
enforcement of the FSAP.
-
The pursuit of home country regulation and minimization of host country regulation.
-
The creation of lead regulators to co-ordinate cross-border activities.
-
Strengthening of competition policy at the EU as well as at the domestic level to prevent
discrimination against cross-border activity.
-
The determination of lender of last resort facilities in the EU.
The integration programme has had a profound impact on the structure of EU banking markets.
Integration has advanced through increased cross-border flows and not much through cross-border
expansion. This domestic restructuring wave has led to an increase in the size of banks in all markets,
and promoted the convergence of market structures, with large increases in bank size and concentration
ratios in the more fragmented markets.
Their analysis finds that country-specific forces are
stronger than initially anticipated; in particular, economic forces, like the importance of
long-term relationships, have been underestimated.
The findings of the Report imply that enacting legislation forcing the opening of
entry in banking markets may not be enough to achieve a fully integrated market. The local
market nature of banking competition makes it harder for legislative moves to reach a high level
of market integration in some retail banking activities. Overall, the experience in the EU, even
after the creation of the euro area, reveals that market integration has progressed very slowly.
A main unresolved issue is what lies behind the barriers to further market integration in
retail banking.
The easy and immediate answer is proximity to customers, advantages from local information and
relationship business. However, the several unsuccessful cases of entry attempts into foreign
retail banking markets, namely in the smaller European markets, suggests that other factors may
be at play as well. In particular, loans to residential consumers are markets where local
presence and nationality still matter. A natural reference point to assess retail banking
integration is the cost of cross-border transactions and by this measure barriers are still
significant. The mere deployment of branch networks is no guarantee of the success of cross-border
expansion.
Theories of corporate finance suggest that information problems are more serious in equity
than in debt finance as a consequence of the greater information sensitivity of equity finance.
The authors therefore predicted that in a ranking of financial integration it would be most in
evidence in public debt markets, least in private equity markets and somewhere in between in private
debt and public equity markets. In fact, what is observed is high level of cross-border flows in
private equity and only modest integration of syndicated bank lending. The authors provide a careful
look at the banking systems of the accession countries.
The Report finds that the banking systems
of these countries have gone through remarkable institutional development and integration of
ownership, with Western European banks controlling most of the important institutions in the
new member states. Old institutions have been transformed, and new ones created. However,
the integration project is far from over. Real integration has proceeded quite far in response
to the liberalization of trade, but financial integration remains incomplete.
Contact Information:
Contact Information: For interview requests and further information about CEPR please
contact CEPR Press Officer Robbie Lonie, Tel: (44 20) 7878 2919, Mobile: 07740519225 or email
rlonie@cepr.org. Visit our website for a copy of this
document or for additional services: http://www.cepr.org
Notes for Editors:
CEPR is a network of 600 Research Fellows based throughout Europe, who
collaborate through the Centre in research and its dissemination. CEPR helps its Research
Fellows to develop projects, obtain their funding, administer them and disseminate their results.
The Centre's research ranges from open economy macroeconomics to trade policy, from the economic transformation of Central and Eastern Europe to regionalism in the world economy.
The BBVA Foundation (FBBVA) was established in 1988 as part of the corporate social engagement of the BBVA banking and financial services group. Its mission is to bring advanced scientific knowledge to bear on the main problems and challenges facing today's society, and to place the results at the service of the broad community. The areas identified as strategic for these purposes are social sciences, biomedicine and the natural environment. FBBVA adheres at all times to the standards of the scientfic community, is scrupulous in respecting scientific objectivity, and does not subscribe to any political, religous or moral creed.
|