DP16354 Identification of Average Marginal Effects in Fixed Effects Dynamic Discrete Choice Models

Author(s): Victor Aguirregabiria, Jesus Carro
Publication Date: July 2021
Keyword(s): Average marginal effects, Dynamic demand of differentiated products, dynamic discrete choice, Fixed effects models, identification, panel data, State Dependence
JEL(s): C23, C25, C51
Programme Areas: Industrial Organization
Link to this Page: cepr.org/active/publications/discussion_papers/dp.php?dpno=16354

In nonlinear panel data models, fixed effects methods are often criticized because they cannot identify average marginal effects (AMEs) in short panels. The common argument is that the identification of AMEs requires knowledge of the distribution of unobserved heterogeneity, but this distribution is not identified in a fixed effects model with a short panel. In this paper, we derive identification results that contradict this argument. In a panel data dynamic logic model, and for T as small as four, we prove the point identification of different AMEs, including causal effects of changes in the lagged dependent variable or in the duration in last choice. Our proofs are constructive and provide simple closed-form expressions for the AMEs in terms of probabilities of choice histories. We illustrate our results using Monte Carlo experiments and with an empirical application of a dynamic structural model of consumer brand choice with state dependence.