DP4248 Old Sins: Exchange Rate Clauses and European Foreign Lending in the 19th Century
|Author(s):||Marc Flandreau, Nathan Sussman|
|Publication Date:||February 2004|
|Keyword(s):||exchange clauses, key currencies, N32, original sin, sovereign debt|
|Programme Areas:||International Macroeconomics|
|Link to this Page:||cepr.org/active/publications/discussion_papers/dp.php?dpno=4248|
This Paper challenges a popular explanation for ?original sin? - the default prone borrowing of long term debt in foreign exchange by emerging markets - that emphasizes the lack of credibility and commitment of governments that prevents them from borrowing in their own currency. Basing our account on the history of emerging market borrowing in the nineteenth century, we offer an explanation based on historical path dependence. We document that almost all IPO?s of governments in foreign markets were in foreign exchange, or with foreign exchange clauses, independent of those countries? institutional features. We show that a small number of countries could circulate debt denominated in their own currency in secondary markets, again irrespective of their constitutional set-up. We argue that market liquidity can explain both phenomena. Having an internationally circulating currency allows countries to circulate their debt in secondary markets. Going for an IPO in a large financial centre is an attempt to tap the greater liquidity of that centre?s money market and currency. It makes perfect sense to borrow then, in that centre?s currency. The evolution of vehicle currencies and liquid money markets has more to do with historical evolution of trade, going back to medieval times, rather than with institutional reform. Escaping from original sin requires that the country emerge as a leading economic power - a rare historical event, reserved for the US of the nineteenth century and Japan of the twentieth century.