DP17039 Double Auctions and Transaction Costs
We show how transaction costs may fundamentally alter incentives and welfare in markets. We identify two categories of transaction costs. Uniform transaction costs — such as fixed and price fees — guarantee positive revenue and are asymptotically strategyproof, but incur unavoidable dead-weight loss. Discriminatory transaction costs — such as spread fees — can avoid dead-weight loss but lead to complex strategic behavior that depends on traders’ beliefs, even in large markets. Depending on traders’ beliefs, the outcomes range from positive revenue with no dead-weight loss to complete market failure.