|
|
"Micro'
Economics
The advent of microcomputers has radically altered both the costs of
and opportunities for empirical research by economists. Even more rapid
changes can be expected over the next few years. As the master of the
small screen said, "You ain't seen nothing yet'. Large machines
will still be necessary where substantial computing power is required,
but microcomputers offer real advantages in three areas: (i) interaction
between researcher and data, (ii) ease of use and (iii) portability and
communications.
The traditional description of economic research draws a clear
distinction between the development of a theory and its subsequent
testing by rigorous statistical methods. Indeed it is often thought that
these two steps are performed by different researchers, the theorist who
formulates a hypothesis and the econometrician who tests whether the
hypothesis is rejected by the data. In fact, empirical work rarely
proceeds in this way. Ideas are suggested by empirical regularities (or
irregularities, as with the sharp rise in the savings ratio in the
1970s), and there is a constant interplay between specification and
testing of a model. This process can be accelerated if the researcher
can work interactively with his data. Microcomputers offer much greater
opportunities for such interactive work than do existing mainframe
facilities.
These opportunities are also enhanced by the ease with which
microcomputers can be used and the availability of specialist software
for economists. The phenomenal expansion of microcomputing has
encouraged the market to provide a wide range of software. Economists
already benefit from the financial incentives facing software houses to
produce high quality and "user-friendly' programs for business use.
Finally, access to data banks and programs produced by economists both
at home and abroad will be made easier by the growth of communications
facilities and the "program portability' afforded by
microcomputers. For example, on a recent visit to the US, I was able to
demonstrate a program an hour after my arrival! In contrast,
transferring data and software from one mainframe to another can be
tiresome at best and impossible at worst. Microcomputers can
significantly lower the cost of research projects involving
international collaboration and comparisons.
A wide range of programs suitable for economists are now available for
microcomputers. These include statistical packages - my own favourite,
shortly to be released in the US, is "PSA', which is specifically
designed for cross-section analysis. The economist now has access to a
variety of programming languages (the problems with the early versions
of FORTRAN have largely been overcome), as well as graphics packages and
word processors. "Spreadsheet' packages such as Lotus 1-2-3 are
particularly useful for the manipulation, transformation and display of
data sets. Two of my own projects can further illustrate how
microcomputers can be used in applied, policy-oriented research.
In the 1984 Budget the Chancellor changed the corporate tax system,
removed tax relief on life insurance policies and abolished the
investment income surcharge. He said that his main aim was to reduce the
enormous variation in effective tax rates on different types of saving
and investment. The extent of this variation, both before and after the
Budget changes, can be calculated using the microcomputer-based program
"PTAX' that I constructed for just this purpose. The user of "PTAX'
can alter the corporate and personal tax rates and simulate the effects
of various reforms. "PTAX' was the result of a research project to
examine effective tax rates in different countries, and the results of
the project were cited by the Treasury in its evidence to the Select
Committee following the Budget.
To evaluate the consequences of "supply-side' policies (such as a
reduction in marginal tax rates to improve efficiency) it is important
to measure the gains and losses they create. Michael Weisbach (MIT) and
I have developed "MICROTRAP', a programme that runs on a personal
computer. "MICROTRAP' calculates the distribution of gains and
losses from a change in the taxation of earnings and the resulting
changes in labour supply. The user of "MICROTRAP' can, without any
knowledge of computer programming, change the entire structure of the
tax system and, for example, simulate the recent US Treasury proposals
for a much smaller number of tax brackets and lower tax rates. A very
important feature of "MICROTRAP' is its ability to examine the
sensitivity of the gains and losses to a wide range of assumptions about
labour supply responses. The user does not have to take anyone else's
results on trust. This DIY approach to the analysis of tax reform will
increase the impact of empirical research on the analysis and
formulation of economic policy.
Mervyn King
Mervyn King is Professor of Economics at the London School of Economics
and a CEPR Research Fellow. The cross-country comparison of effective
tax rates is described in "The Taxation of Income from Capital' by
M A King and D Fullerton (University of Chicago Press, 1984).
Information on the "PTAX' and "MICROTRAP' programs is
available from Professor King at the London School of Economics.
|
|