Enterprise Reform
Hungarian privatization

Various changes in ownership structure in the past five years have reflected the influence of political factors on government priorities in Hungary. By mid-1993, widespread renationalization had successfully re-established state control of many firms. The effects of this mandatory corporatization and the earlier `spontaneous privatization' on enterprise behaviour appear broadly similar. In Discussion Paper No. 916, Éva Voszka argues, however, that the two types of companies that result differ in their form and thus also in their interests. `Spontaneous privatization' strengthened enterprise management's proprietary rights vis-à-vis a weak structure of central administration. It also diversified investors, even within the state sector, by involving banks and partner companies as shareholders, although many of the resulting `holdings' then had to sell their shares or assets to survive. Centralization, in contrast, is creating a monolithic, administrative proprietor intent on re-establishing its direct influence. Managers may nevertheless prefer formal subordination to state ownership over strong private ownership, however, if this promises to bring an end to political threats and an opportunity to enforce their own interests by assuming the proper managerial role long denied them under central planning.

The major issue for privatization in Hungary now is whether new methods of redistribution will complement the existing ones and the range of assets they will cover. While the Czech approach of broad-based, free distribution involves high political risks, the promises and preparations of recent months suggest that some new distribution methods may be introduced. While the government could not afford a full withdrawal, the available alternatives range from free to repayable shares in large and small amounts. Renationalization of state enterprises need not lead to redistribution, but current circumstances make this seem increasingly likely.

Centralization, Renationalization, Redistribution. The Role of the Government in Changing the Ownership Structure in Hungary, 1989-93
Éva Voszka

Discussion Paper No. 916, February 1994 (AM)